Skip to main content

Macbeth, Manhood and T****

I'm watching several versions of Macbeth and I keep thinking two things.  

I admit to not having watched much Shakespeare, so it is perhaps normal for him to talk to often about experiencing the world either as a man vs. as a woman.  But it definitely seems to be a theme in Macbeth.  It is also possible that I am seeing this through the twin lenses of #MeToo and Man v. Bear.  That said, seems to me that Shakespeare was talking shit about what it means to be a man LONG before any modern sensibility about men being dangerous.  

The thing I kept hearing repeated again and again was how, in order to do the difficult (in this case meaning both "wrong" and "criminal") things, you had to be manly.  Lady Macbeth (whose real name is Gruoch ... Gruoch ingen Boite ... and I can't fault Shakespeare for not using it) fears her husband is too full of "the milk of human kindness" to do what is necessary and, later, says that when he completes the deed, THEN he will be a man.  Later, she prays to be "unsexed" so that she, too, can participate in the "manly" act of regicide without remorse. When Macbeth is confronted by his guilt in the form of Banquo's ghost at the banquet, Lady Macbeth again questions his manhood.  Later, Macbeth is able to kill all feelings of propriety and guilt which allow him to kill MacDuff's wife and children without thinking twice or feeling any remorse afterwards.  He has become a manly-man.

Again and again, there is this idea that manhood somehow means an inability to feel and the ability to do all manner of wrongs sans regret.  What kills me is that it appears Shakespeare is deriding that idea because Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are clearly the villains of the play.  And yet ... that appears to be the current definition.  The same characteristics that led Macbeth and all those in his orbit to ruin are what I hear we've lost in our increasing "feminization" or "unmanning" or whatever it is that supposedly happened to our culture.  

Which leads me to T****.  He is, absolutely, the poster-child of the broken image of manhood currently espoused by himself and his MAGAts.  As soon as that thought struck me, I was struck by another.  What if the character of Macbeth were replaced by T****?  I was immediately laughing and horrified in equal measure.  Laughing because ... well ... could you imagine the dialogue? 

Blood-bolted Banquo smiled upon me
Big man, strong man,
Tears streaming down his ghostly face
And he said to me,
"I'm so grateful that you killed me
because you really should be king of Scotland,
and really England, too, 
and France, 
Just everywhere."

Melania should have died hereafter,
but there's a lot of other women who want to be with me,
tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow,
which is a funny word, why not just one morrow?
Two for morrow, one for joy.
That way for dusty death
except not for me
because my physiker said I'm still healthy,
not like crooked Joe MacDuff...

But horrified because the play couldn't be done with T**** in the place of Macbeth.  Macbeth, at least in the beginning, has some reservation about doing the bad things.  And the majority of the second act is him wrestling with his guilt.  Can anyone imagine T**** feeling anything akin to remorse or doubt for any action that he does, regardless of cause or consequence?  The main conflict of the play would be rendered pointless.  

That was our president.  And, God help us, may be again.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Ballad of Murdoch

I had to euthanize my cat, Murdoch, on January 9th.  There's really only one other person (my wife) who gets how amazing he was.  But trying to explain it would be frustrating to me (because I would fail) and oppressive to others (because it would be the equivalent of subjecting them to a slideshow of a vacation with the added bonus of feeling compelled to listen because it's about a dead cat).  So, imma write about it here and then if you want to read it ... well ... that's on you.  I won't know either way.   Context first.  I moved to NY in 2021 to help my sister open a vet clinic.  I cashed out my entire life in NC and came up alone, the first time I'd been truly alone in probably three decades.  My sister lived down the road, but ... still.  It's hard to convey exactly how much of an uprooting it was for me at almost 50 years old.  We opened the clinic in early 2022.  Up until this point, while I'd always liked cats, I defi...

Brian Thompson and Syndrome

The Titanic submarine sank killing all passengers in mid-June.  I was surprised at the glee some, even some people I knew to be very caring, had at their demise.  When I asked one person, they replied that all those rich bastards likely deserved it.  When I mentioned there were younger people on board, they said, "Well, they'd probably just grow up like their dads."  Kill Hitler as a baby, I guess?  I didn't quite get the vitriol JUST because they were rich.  And, I guess, reckless and stupid.   But the murder of Brian Thompson, the late United Healthcare CEO ... that one I get.  It's not just because he's rich.  It's because his wealth was founded on the deaths of so many people that he and his company wrongly denied healthcare coverage.  I don't think I need to go into the specifics of the murder.  It's covered a LOT in the media right now.  As is the reaction.  People are, again, gleeful.  But it's more than j...

Flag Turned Upside Down

I've heard the recent hullabaloo about Justice Alito flying an upside down United States flag and the Appeal to Heaven flag at his house.  Both flags have apparently been co-opted by proponents of the "stolen election" conspiracy theory.  Alito, being the good Catholic that he is, pulled an Adam and blamed his wife.  As it turns out, she is actually the vexillologist of the family and has even designed an anti-Pride flag (using the Italian word for shame).   But what got me was that the upside down flag and the Appeal to Heaven flag were so thoroughly associated with MAGAts.  I mean ... sure, if I see an upside down flag flown from a house these days, I assume they're a certain type of extreme right-winger and that is usually confirmed by other displays around the house.  But the Appeal to Heaven flag?  I don't ever remember seeing that flown on January 6th.  I mean, sure, the Gadsden Flag , which I used to like, has become associated with ...